logo_c

Notes on the interpretation of GDR measurement results

The human body is permanently exposed to external ionising radiation originating from the natural environment. It is comprised of a terrestrial and a cosmic component. The first component comes from natural radioactive substances, i.e. radionuclides, like uranium, thorium, and potassium (40K). The second component is produced by high energy particles from outer space which are hitting the earth's atmosphere. Most of these particles are absorbed within the atmosphere, but a small fraction still reaches the ground.

Natural Radiation

The total amount of radiation, i.e. its energy-impact per mass unit for a fixed period of time, the so-called GDR or Gamma Dose Rate, is measured in units of μSv/h (micro Sievert per hour). The natural GDR in Germany ranges between 0.05 μSv/h and 0.2 μSv/h. Additional radiation originating from the Chernobyl accident in 1986 contributes only a very small proportion to the local gamma dose rate today.

At the same location the natural GDR is usually more or less constant over time. Figure 1 displays a typical time series of the GDR at the monitoring station 010590751 in the city of Schleswig for the time interval from 13. April 2011 to 15. April 2011. No rain-events, no snow-coverage, and no technical interferences are visible there.


  Fig. 1: Standard time series at a monitoring station in the city of Schleswig

  Fig. 2: Time series with short rain-events

Short period peaks of the GDR, up to a factor of 2, occur when radioactive progeny (daughter nuclides) of the radioactive noble gas radon (Rn-222) are deposited on the ground by rain. Such events are usually correlated with precipitation. Typically the increase is steep and the signal asymptotically returns to the normal level within a few hours. The typical half-life time of this decay is about 30 minutes.

In Figure 2, the effect of some rain-events in a time series taken at a monitoring station in the village of Todendorf is shown. Beside the GDR (black line), the time series of a corresponding weather radar signal (measured by the DWD, the German Weather Service) is shown (red line). The signal height of the weather radar is proportional to the density of clouds. A high density most likely indicates precipitation. Coinciding with the radar signal one can see the short-lived increase of the GDR.

Snowfall, like rain can also lead to an increase of the GDR, particularly if the ground previously was not covered by snow. In addition to short-term variations, the GDR often shows also long-term variations within the course of the year. A layer of snow or ice on the ground generally causes the GDR to decrease because the radiation originating from the ground is partly absorbed by the snow layer. With the onset of thawing, when the snow is melting, the GDR increases until it reaches its previous level again. Similarly, soil moisture, which in turn depends on the local geology, soil surface characteristics and on microclimate conditions, can lead to variations of the GDR of up to some 0.01 μSv/h (micro Sievert per hour).


  Fig. 3: Example of a GDR time series with snow coverage

Variations of the measured GDR

Radiological events or technical problems can cause variations of the GDR much larger than the natural effects described above. Technical problems (e.g. long periods of mains failure, uninterrupted power supply battery fault, degradation of a Geiger-Müller tube, etc.) as well as radiological events are recognised, when the GDR exceeds a given threshold-value. The data logger locally detects such variations and problems and sends an automatic warning. In the case of a threshold warning the operator on duty will be alarmed immediately if two such events occur within one hour and at less than 30km distance apart. During routine operation of the monitoring network, all measurement results exceeding the given thresholds (automatically labelled as: ''to be examined'') are checked by a human operator daily. Hence problems and radiological events will be noted immediately. Since the low-dose Geiger-Müller counters are very sensitive they are also very susceptible to many kinds of perturbations. Interferences in the measurement-chain (probe, data logger, voltage-supply) or a lightning event close to the measuring station can influence the GDR. In Figures 4 - 8, some interferences are presented that occur quite often.


A typical behaviour of a GDR time series from a broken low-dose Geiger-Müller-counter is shown in Figure 4. After normal behaviour, the values suddenly start jumping atypically and stepwise. In this particular case the malfunction is explained by a malfunction of the high dose tube arbitrarily disturbing the data. The data logger detects this failure as the breakdown of a counter tube and sends a corresponding spontaneous message to that monitoring network node of the BfS (Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz, Engl. Federal Office for Radiation Protection) that is responsible for this monitoring station.


  Fig. 4: Broken low-dose Geiger-Müller-counter

  Fig. 5: Neither low-dose nor high-dose Geiger-Müller-counter are delivering signals

If the data logger does not get signals from either the low-dose or the high-dose Geiger-Müller-counter, the calculation and subsequent transmission of GDR-values by the data logger is no longer possible. The most common cause for such a coincidental missing of signals from both Geiger-Müller-counters is a cut in the cable between probe and data logger. Another typical cause for such a failure is the breakdown of the probe's electronics.

At locations extraordinarily exposed to wind, it is possible that the probe oscillates on its pole. When the resonance frequency is met, the anode-wire of the low-dose Geiger-Müller-counter also oscillates and the distance between the anode-wire and the cathode becomes close enough for spontaneous gas discharges, i.e. sparks. These sparks mimic real signals induced by gamma rays and consequently are interpreted as such by the data logger. There is no regular pattern either in amplitudes or shape. The corresponding augmentations might stop after several hours and may start again after a while (see Figure 6). In order to fix this problem the probe is exchanged or a more massive standpipe is used. Eventually as a last resort, the probe is moved to a less exposed position.


  Fig. 6: Wind effect

  Fig. 7: Doubling error

Significant regular increase of the signal might be ''measured'' due to a so-called echo effect. The GDR, suddenly jumps to values roughly twice as high as before (see Figure 7). Typically, an hour later the GDR returns to the previous level. This phenomenon predominantly shows up at higher temperatures and with older Geiger-Müller-counters with old counting gas.

A regular gamma-ray induced pulse into the counter tube is then followed by one, sometimes even more echo pulses. This malfunction of the probe is counted by the electronics as a normal signal and thus, is giving an approximately doubled GDR-value. Another counter detects the occurrence of the echo due to the small time interval between both pulses and counts the number of echo signals separately. Thus the malfunction can be detected quickly and the probe can be replaced.

Sometimes single spikes up to several 0.1 μSv/h can be found in a GDR time series which do not follow any chronological regularity (see Figure 8). Most of such spikes come from electromagnetic perturbations captured by the cables between probe and data logger. With the newer, technically more advanced probes such spikes have become very rare.


  Fig. 8: Single spikes

Summary

The samples discussed here cover only a small part of all the possible interferences in the monitoring network. Malfunctioning probes are rapidly changed or repaired. Since the BfS is checking all data daily in routine operation, strangely behaving probes are quickly detected and if really broken, immediately labelled ''defect'' in the data base of the BfS monitoring network. In consequence, these probes are no longer used for pre-alarm. These stations might however, despite their status, deliver data open to public access via internet. The displayed 1-hour-data are indeed raw-data which are not necessarily free from technical perturbations.

Any irregular GDR value is reviewed by a specialised BfS operator. If the irregularity cannot be explained by known natural or technical effects and particularly if the dose rate increases over a longer time period or is beyond natural effects, BfS will take further steps to clarify if the data show evidence of an undisclosed radiological event and trigger appropriate action.

THE GERMAN GDR-NETWORK

In the Federal Republic of Germany, the monitoring of environmental radioactivity was initiated in the middle of the 1950s induced by the increase of artificial environmental radioactivity resulting from the nuclear weapon tests and their possible effect on public health. Continuous measurements are carried out on land, in the air, in rivers and offshore. Moreover, periodical measurements of radioactivity in food e.g. game, fish, mushrooms, field crops as well as in the soil complete the protection against artificial radioactivity. The German Federal Office for Radiation Protection (Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz, BfS) is one institute that works for the safety and protection of man and the environment against damage due to ionising radiation. To measure an increase in the radioactivity in the environment, the BfS operates a network of about 1800 stationary gamma dose rate probes that entirely and homogeneously covers the whole country in a grid of about 15 km x 15 km. The gamma dose rate (GDR) is given in the unit micro sievert per hour (µSv/h). The network is operated by 6 monitoring network nodes of the Bundesamt für Strahlenschutz (Federal Office for Radiation Protection), BfS, which are located in Berlin, Bonn, Freiburg, Neuherberg (close to Munich), Rendsburg, and Salzgitter. Besides the automatic monitoring stations mobile detection-systems for nuclide identification via spectroscopic measurements are operated by each of the network nodes.

The Figure on the right shows an example of an installed GDR-probe in Germany on the island Vilm. Such a probe contains two Geiger-Müller counters for measuring the GDR. The data logger (Messwertsender) which is connected to the probe by cable accumulates the data into 1- and 10-minute average values and sends these values on a regular basis to server stations of the corresponding network nodes. In the case of a technical problem or a GDR increase beyond a given threshold an automatic message is sent immediately by the data logger. In order to get comparable data from probes distributed all over the country it is important to ask for certain criteria concerning the condition of locations for probe installation. An optimal location is a flat lawn or meadow without trees, higher-growing plants, sealed areas, or buildings in the vicinity of the probe.

The Chernobyl reactor accident in 1986 showed that radioactive contamination of the environment is a large scale phenomenon. Since it cannot be ruled out that such an event might happen again, the BfS GDR network is the main route for the acquisition of information on the propagation of a radioactive cloud over Germany. Even a slight increase of the gamma dose rate triggers an automatic pre-alarm, which activates the BfS team on duty. The BfS specialists check the measurements and alert the emergency services in the case of a possible artificial gamma dose rate signal. The measurements are very sensitive, and as a result pre-alarm situations caused by weather conditions occur about 50 times per year. In the case of a real radioactive emergency the network can operate in intensive mode, i.e. the data from all measuring points are collected in 10-minute intervals, in order to promptly register a possible change of the radiological situation online. The computer systems of the measuring and service centres are designed with linked redundant capacity (six parallel independent systems located in 6 different computer centres distributed over Germany). Thus it is ensured, that in the case of a computer failure the tasks from one system are taken over by another computer centre without any time delay.

Related links


  Fig. 9: GDR-Probe used in the network

  Fig. 10: MWS3 Data logger housing